Home

General Information

About Us


CVC Audit Information Download


Contact Us


Display Advertising


Ad Sizes and Samples


Classified Advertising

Communities

Communities Served


Community Resources

-$- Online Store -$-

Digital Online Subscription


Order A Classified Ad Online


Place Assumed Name Notice


Cook County Legals Printed Here


Kane County Name Change - $85


Place Obituary Notice


Download Sample Paper

Submission of News

Engagement Submittal


Birth Announcements


News & Photos


Sports Scores

Lifestyle Features and Videos

Food and Lifestyle


Lifestyle Videos


Seasonal Widget


Crossword and Sudoku Puzzles


Mug Shot Mania News

Online News and Commentary

The Examiner U-46 News Feed


Cheap Seats 2024 By Rich Trzupek


Cheap Seats 2023 By Rich Trzupek


Cheap Seats 2022 By Rich Trzupek


Guest Seat By Harold Pease, Ph.D.


Cheap Seats 2021 By Rich Trzupek


Cheap Seats 2020


Cheap Seats 2019


Cheap Seats 2018


Cheap Seats 2017


Cheap Seats 2016


Cheap Seats 2015 B


Cheap Seats 2015


Cheap Seats 2014


Cheap Seats 2013


Cheap Seats 2012


Cheap Seats 2011


Cheap Seats 2010


Ramey DUI Video


Representative Randy Ramey pleads guilty to DUI


Bartlett Volunteer Fire Department Street Dance


The Truth about Global Warming


Examiner Editorials and Cheap Seats from the past

Forms and Newsstand Locations

Newsstand Locations


Carriers needed


Legal Newspaper

Cheap Seats 2023 By Rich Trzupek

Much to do About Nothing - 04/05


By Rich Trzupek
  Are polyfluoroalkyl substances, generically known as PFAS, a clear and present danger to the health and welfare of Americans? What is the best strategy to mitigate the PFAS threat to human health and the environment? As importantly, how big of a threat are PFAS compounds to either?
  It’s unlikely that we’ll ever get honest answers to those questions. The independent, rational, scientific traditions that encouraged critical thinking and informed disagreement is fading away in western civilization In it’s place, we are increasingly subject to state-approved science formulated by armies of technocrats and administered by legions of bureaucrats.  When the scientific method is eventually dead and buried, I have a suggestion for the epitaph to be engraved on its tombstone: “Expired better safe than sorry.”
  Those words, “better safe than sorry,” concisely express the essence of the Precautionary Principle. The Precautionary Principle, in turn, is a bane of modern existence. It’s a societal plague that breeds cowardice, inhibits progress and encourages insularity in thought and in practice. The Biden administration’s plans to address the “PFAS crisis” is the latest example of the left applying the Precautionary Principle to justify heavy-handed government policies.
  The acronym PFAS stands for polyfluoroalkyl substances. This designation encompasses hundreds of chemicals that share important chemical characteristics, although many do not fit neatly under the PFAS banner to those of us intimately familiar with chemical naming conventions.  However, all do include the element fluorine.
  To a chemist fluorine is one of the most remarkable elements on the periodic table. It forms incredibly strong bonds with other atoms, giving PFAS chemicals their unique characteristics and their resiliency. The last is especially troublesome to the EPA and environmental groups who have dubbed PFAS “forever chemicals.” The implication being that once created they are impossible to get rid of. That’s not entirely accurate, but it must be admitted that getting rid of PFAS compounds does take a bit more work than your run of the mill waste product.
  Aren’t we be concerned about these forever chemicals? There’s two parts to that question. First does having a particular chemical in your system for a long time necessarily harm your system? The answer to that depends on the chemical and the dose. It would be fair to call silicon dioxide, what we commonly call sand, a “forever chemical” every bit as much as PFAS. Absent willful and energetic processing sand is sand and will remain sand. So do we worry if we ingest some sand into our system? If it’s not much and it’s in our gastrointestinal system the body recognizes it as a waste, something it has no use for, and will pass it through the GI tract and colon to be eliminated.
  I am not a biologist. So I do not know if PFAS compounds bioaccumulate in the body in part or in whole. If they do they certainly don’t accumulate in substantial amounts. We can say that because when people have conducted studies and found PFAS in the water, in the air, and in the soil they find it in concentrations that are in the parts per trillion or less levels.
  A part per trillion is an incredibly small concentration. It is the equivalent of one drop of water in enough water to fill 20 Olympic-sized swimming pools. Twenty to 30 years ago we didn’t even have the technology that would allow us to look at these extremely low concentrations. Are concentrations that low a significant threat to human health and the environment? I cannot answer that question definitively, but I don’t think anyone else can answer that question definitively either.
  When EPA and environmental groups talk about PFAS They inevitably choose verbs that allow them to hedge their bets. Verbs like “may” and “could” and “suggests.” As in: “Research suggests that these compounds may be associated with – fill name of your favorite scary disease - and that these effects may be more serious among the elderly and newborn children.”
  Definitive verbs are to be avoided at all costs, like will or does or demonstrates. It takes years of indoctrination by the technocrats and the bureaucrats before they’ll move up to definitive verbs. At that point the war is over and the scientists have lost. There was a time when climate change was discussed as a potential threat, as a hypothesis worth examining, but not as a proven fact. We are well beyond that point today. Every politician, every journalist, every representative of an environmental NGO talks about climate change in terms of certainty. They assure us that the science is settled. The EPA’s PFAS Strategic Road Map puts us well on the way to settling this rather dubious bit of science as well.
  I cannot assert that parts per trillion levels of these compounds are not a serious threat to human health and the environment. Nor can I assert they are. I doubt if there’s any single scientist who can say one way or the other. I doubt there is anyone who can say pursuing this research is worth the cost compared to other priorities the EPA might be pursuing. But I can predict the EPA will follow its usual playbook: Develop a large set of very restrictive rules, very expensive rules, whose cost will be justified by the theoretical reduction in the hospitalizations and death that will be assumed. Not proven. Assumed. That’s what inevitably happens. At one point during the Obama administration EPA Director Lisa Jackson claimed so much savings from environmental regulations that we could have paid off the national debt had her numbers been accurate.
  New rules are coming that will affect regulations covering water, covering land, covering the air, covering waste disposal, covering approval of new and existing chemicals. These rules will largely be developed by the technocrats and bureaucrats alone. Yes, once they’re developed there will be comment periods and the various agencies will be flooded with comments. As a result of the comments there’ll be a change here and a change there but really no substantive changes in direction. The rules are developed in an echo chamber where only cheerleaders are present. Only then are they presented to the public, including many scientists who may disagree with the assumptions made when developing the rules. No matter. Experience shows that what is finally approved will look much like whatever is first proposed.
  It’s possible this effort could become another bust like Alar, toxic mold and endocrine disruptors. All of those crises of the day more or less went away after time. Maybe it will be the same with PFAS. But given the way that fantasies have materialized into so-called realities so quickly over the last few years I fear that massive investments in PFAS regulations, controls and clean-up will be a part of our lives for a long time to come.
  Email: RichTrzupek@gmail.com




©2024 Examiner Publications, Inc.

Website Powered by Web Construction Set